Monday, August 24, 2009

Mob Rule, Healthcare Style


You wanna talk all old-school? Then remember this rule:
 I am the one  who calls the shots!
-Tony Soprano

Fomer House Speaker Newt Gingrich had an interesting piece in the Washington Examiner last week, comparing House Energy and Commerce Committee poopah Henry Waxman to TV Mafioso Tony Soprano. I think we're making  progress when the two sides in the healthcare debate stop referring to each other as "Hitler" and wick the rhetoric back to TV crime characters.

Chairman Waxman has sent a letter to over 50 of the nation's largest health insurers demanding they produce for him a pile of information. This information includes:

  • what their best paid executives make
  • where the companies hold their offsite meetings
  • who sits on their boards of directors and what they get paid

Why? Speaker Gingrich says its part of a coordinated attack by Democrats to intimidate insurance companies in the midst of the healthcare battle. What's curious to me is the fact that there are multiple stakeholders that have shaped our current healthcare system. For example:

  • The Congress which has mandated that hospitals eat the bill for treating those without insurance, the unintended consequence of which has been to pass that cost on to the rest of us with insurance
  • The tort bar, which has made billions of dollars on spurious suits against healthcare providers and their insurance companies, further raising healthcare costs and insurance rates
  • A succession of DHHS agency executives who have let Medicare and Medicaid fraud and explode over the last 30 years
  • International pharmaceutical companies whose pricing schemes are more opaque and confusing than airline fares
  • Providers who no longer accept Medicare or Medicaid patients, partly because of conditions imposed on them by DHHS and state agencies
Why haven't they been drawn into this Inquisition? Could it have something to do with the fact that associations and lobbyists supporting the drug industry and doctors have cut what they feel is the best deal they can get and are supporting the Democrats' monster bill? And that the national Democrat Party has for years been the handmaiden of the tort bar?

This is intimidation, plain and simple, says Speaker Gingrinch. No different than if Vito and Paulie pay you a visit one night because you're a little behind on the vig.

Waxman may rough up the insurance execs a little. His bill, frankly, will go to the floor in any shape he wants it to. The House may pass it. The Senate and House may eventually send a bill to the president. He may sign it, giving Democrats the brave new world of healthcare they seek. But any law built on intimidation and bullying will have about has much legitimacy as a contract put out by an angry capo.

Just thought you might like to know. 



Friday, August 21, 2009

Welcome to the Fun House


The Fun House that is the national healthcare debate has more trap doors and surprises than you can imagine. With the 1,018 page (That's not writing legislation; that's typing legislation) House healthcare bill stalled, the Democrats are trying a new tactic to backdoor government-controlled healthcare. 

First "healthcare reform" morphed in the Fun House mirror into "healthcare insurance reform," when the American people dug their heels in. Then the so-called "public option" disappeared through a trap door, and the "insurance cooperatives" suddenly fell from the ceiling. Now the back door of the Fun House has opened and we're staring at the latest Freddy Kreuger tactic from  socialized healthcare proponents. They are starting to push on the state level to get state after state to socialize their health care. From their perspective, it's just a matter of time till Uncle Sam connects the dots and nationalized the healthcare industry.

The latest battleground is Pennsylvania. Democrats are moving a bill through the legislature that would, they say, provide free universal healthcare for all Pennsylvanians. "They say" is the key thing to remember.

Pennsylvania's Senate Bill 400/House Bill 1660 is a piece of work only politicians up for reelection could love. Free healthcare, no deductibles, no co-pays, nobody ineligible, no preexisting conditions. No exclusions Nothing. Free. Free. Free. Ain't life grand? Only problem is that in this world if you're a consumer, nothing's free.

Here's why. The Promise Them Everything Health Care Act is financed by a 3% tax on individuals and a whopping 10% tax on business payrolls. In a recession. When bankruptcies are already at their highest point in years. In a rust-belt state with an economy largely stuck in the 1950s. With one of the highest proportions of elderly citizens of any state. That noise you hear is businesses burning rubber to flee to tax haven Delaware--the Monaco of the East Coast--as fast as they can.

So as these legislative lions try to assure themselves another term by promising a healthcare Garden of Eden, I thought it would be a good thing to take a look a the track record of other states that have bigfooted their way into running healthcare. The record is not good. In fact, it's pretty ugly. Take a look at the results in four states, Tennessee, Maine,  Hawaii and Massachusetts, courtesy of healthcare consultant and analyst Nancy Bucceri of Chaddford Planning Associates:

Tennesee’s TennCare

-         started in 1994 with a $2.6 billion budget.

-         Ran efficiently the first few years

-         By 2004 spending ballooned to $8 billion, one third of the state’s budget

-         By 2005 170,000 beneficiaries had to be cut from the plan

-         45% of people with employer-based coverage left to join TennCare

-         To address costs, benefits were slashed, reimbursement rates were cut

-         Physicians have increasingly declined to accept new patients


 Conclusion:  TennCare has driven the state to near bankruptcy and has not solved the problem of getting affordable healthcare to those who can’t get it elsewhere.

 Maine’s DirigoChoice

-         started in 2003 with $50 million in stimulus money

-         the goal was to cover 128,000 uninsured

-         promised to insure everyone and save patients and businesses money at the same time

-         instead, it is $155 million over budget and rising

-         premiums have risen 74%, pushing most people out of the program

-         only 3,400 are in the program today

 Conclusion:  Maine’s health plan has not met the goal of providing access to healthcare for the uninsured, and yet has increased state spending for healthcare services.

 Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Health Insurance Plan

-         started in 2006, 40% over budget the first year alone

-         30% increase in ER utilization since program inception

-         funding relies heavily on a smoker’s tax (smoking is the leading cause of skyrocketing health costs in the US, but Mass needs people to keep puffing)

-         small businesses have cut jobs, salaries and other benefits to pay for it

-         employers have been reducing benefits, cutting healthcare coverage to the 33.3% minimum

-         over 1,023 employers have opted to pay the fine


 Conclusion:  Massachusetts has successfully increased the number of insured people, but it has not increased access to care and does not have a financially sustainable plan.

Hawaii’s Prepaid Healthcare Act

-         started in 1974.

-         Initially boasted one of  the lowest level of uninsured in the US, but was not lower than many states without universal healthcare

-         Hawaii’s medical cost inflation rate is rising faster than the overall inflation rate in the state (32.6% vs 29.8% between 2000-2008)

-         Uninsured private sector employee rate has risen to 13.25% as employers cut hours to avoid mandate

-         Average cost of premiums to families is $10,000.

 Conclusion:  The program worked for a while but has become financially unsustainable.

Pennsylvania lawmakers want to combine the current state Medicaid plan with coverage for everyone else, essentially running private insurers out of the state. So what's the Commonwealth's track record for managing healthcare insurance? Well, again, pretty ugly. 

The state Medicaid program serves nearly 2 million people already. Like a carnivore, it already consumes over a quarter of the state budget. With annual spending increases of 8%, it's projected to gobble up nearly 90%) pf the entire state budget by 2075. That's if nothing's done. Adding millions more Pennsylvanians to the rolls will only make things worse. 

By the way, about a buck and a half out of every ten tax dollars spent on the Medicaid program in Pennsylvania gets eaten up by fraud. Did I mention that with that kind of insatiable appetite for dollars, Medicaid has a reputation for low quality service? This is the model that politicians want to extend to the non-public assistance population of the state. Just a thought-- why not find ways to extend quality care to the minority of people on Medicaid, rather than the other way around?

The problem with these five states is that state lawmakers are relying on predictive modeling, which has never worked consistently for healthcare. Proof:  Since 1965, the Congressional Budget Office has consistently underestimated the cost of healthcare by as much as a factor of 10.   Government projections of revenue and expenses are unreliable predictors of how healthcare policies are going to play out. 

A better, more reliable way would be to use historic data and case studies in forming healthcare public policy, rather than models that have never proven accurate. But then those facts might get in the way of the optimistic story they're trying to sell to the public. 

Just thought you might like to know.

 

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

Routine No. 1


If media powerhouses like talk radio and Fox News are any indication, the wheels are coming off Barack Obama's longtime ambition to nationalize the U.S. healthcare industry. A July 29 Gallup poll shows that only 44% of Americans believe that the President's plan will result in improvements to healthcare. August has proved a hot month for Democratic congressmen who are getting roasted about the President's plan at town hall meetings across the country.

So the President has gone back to the old-time Democratic pol playbook, and called Routine No. 1. Democrat Routine No. 1 says never argue with conservatives on facts; you can't win. Always argue through emotion. 

Be prepared: The White House says expect a new healthcare sales tactic after Labor Day, when Pres. Obama rolls out a new media attack on conservatives. Out are deficit projections, quality life- year studies, and nuances between a public option and insurance cooperatives. In will be gut wrenching stories about heartless insurance companies and heart-tugging tales by little pigtailed girls about how daddy doesn't have any insurance anymore because he got laid off. 

Expect every television news program break to be crammed with million dollar spots produced by Madison Avenue and paid for by the President's unlikely bedfellows on this backroom political deal: the pharmaceutical industry, the American Medical Association and AARP. 

But don't you believe it. The President is a master of creating bogeymen and rallying support by blaming the bogey. As in his lifting the presidential ban on stem cell research: "Rather than furthering discovery, our government has forced...a false choice between sound science and moral values." In this case Pres. Obama painted his predecessor as a medieval mandarin, unable to reconcile science and religion, when the truth was the opposite. (Pres. Bush's ban led to tremendous strides on other types of cellular research that hold great promise.)

When you're carpet bombed with 30-second spots featuring the new Harry and Louise, cute little kids and huggable grandpas, remember the facts: what the President is desperately reaching for has resulted in rationing, backbreaking costs, and a lack of innovation everywhere it's been tried. Those are the facts.

So don't be impressed at this last-ditch effort at socialism. In 1948, at an Illinois campaign stop, a supporter shouted to Harry Truman during his stump speech, "Give 'em hell, Harry." The President's classic reply: "I don't give them hell. I just tell the truth, and they think it's hell." 

So when they try to hide the facts behind slick commercials and speeches to handpicked audiences, give 'em hell.

Just thought you might like to know.


Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Connecting the Dots


Enjoying a typical East Coast humid August morning, I noticed three disparate stories in the news today.

  • The Wall Street Journal reports this morning that the Obama administration is lending Brazil $2 billion for new oil and gas exploration off its coast

Although these stories are unrelated, they are connected. The Dow lost about 2% of its value yesterday on a realization by Wall Street that, unlike in the past, consumers will probably not be able to spend the nation out of this recession. Consumers remain edgy about spending because of the uncertainty coming from Washington. How to pay for a deficit projected at $17 trillion by 2019, the ultimate shape and cost of healthcare "reform," and an unemployment rate that continues to rise, although more slowly, are all weighing on consumers minds as they make spending choices.

Part of that consumer uncertainty and pessimism is the cost of gasoline. Gasoline is a recurring expense. Every time you fill up you're reminded that prices continue to rise all over. This makes consumers wary of spending. For a consumer-driven economy, that's deadly. Our economy booms when consumers are optimistic, buying everything from durable goods to fishing tackle. When consumers pull back, there are fewer jobs that involve manufacturing, distributing and selling consumer goods. That means less tax revenue and even bigger deficits, which have to be filled by--you guessed it--higher taxes. And the spiral goes downward from there.

Which brings us to Brazil. Now, it might sound odd that a government which is on the verge of having to hold a telethon to raise money to pay its bills is lending a third world country cash to drill for oil off of its coast. Especially when that country has thousand of miles of coastline of its own that hold oil and gas deposits that could greatly lessen our energy dependence on countries like Brazil, Venezuela and the Arab states. In 2007 Enviro-kooks went to court to stop planned oil and gas exploration in Alaska. The Court has said that the ruling just applied to Alaska waters, not the remainder of the Pacific Coast. But the Obama Administration continues to slow walk plans for offshore exploration, in deference to its environmental masters. Meanwhile, we continue to inch back up to $3.00 a gallon.

So if we connect the dots this morning we have consumers voting with their pocketbooks on the economic recovery and the result isn't good. Consumers still don't believe the economic babble coming from Washington about prosperity being just around the corner. One reason is that the volatility of gasoline prices continues to remind us all how fragile our family finances are. And with a chance to encourage optimism, this Administration continues to demonstrate how tone deaf it is to how the American people really feel. Pres. Obama continues to pay homage to the environmental lobby and refuses to do something simple but concrete that will encourage optimism, get people spending again, and achieve real energy independence. 

Just thought you might like to know.

Monday, August 17, 2009

Playing Politics with Healthcare


I had an opportunity this weekend to participate in a “town hall” meeting on healthcare reform. The speaker was U.S. Representative Joe Pitts (R-Pa.) Far from the raucous meetings you see on Fox News or You Tube, this one was pretty sedate. It was held at a Knights of Columbus hall, sponsored by a pro-life group, and attended largely by pro-lifers who have supported Joe Pitts’ pro-life record in Congress. 

            Congressman Pitts is a member of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, one of three House committees that has jurisdiction over the healthcare bill. His talk was interesting because gave an “inside baseball” talk on the negotiations over H.R. 3200, the House’s healthcare reform bill. To understand his actions you have to know that Congressman Pitts chairs something called the Values Action Team, which is a coalition of about 70 congressmen, plus pro-life or pro-family groups like Focus on the Family. 

            The main topic of his remarks was that Committee chairman Henry Waxman and the other leftists in Congress are using healthcare reform as a way to backdoor abortion-on-demand into American public policy. This is occurring in a number of ways.

The Democrat-controlled House bill will mandate that health care providers that accept federal funding will have to offer abortion services or referrals. It will preempt state laws that place conditions on abortions. (About 40 states now have abortion notification provisions.) It will remove Bush-era protections for healthcare providers who refuse to provide abortion referrals or services for reasons of conscience. It will return federal funding for abortions to the District of Columbia. (Three days after his inauguration, Pres. Obama began playing his campaign debit to NARAL and the abortion industry by issuing an executive order that overturned previous prohibitions on federal funding of abortions in overseas family planning programs) 

            Congressman Pitts has offered four amendments to the bill that would restore right-to-life protections. These amendments have been subject to a variety of parliamentary maneuvers on the part of the majority, which will refuse to let them be introduced when the bill gets to the floor for full debate. Such is the state that our government has become. 

            Of course these lions of courage like Henry Waxman and Nancy Pelosi could stand up for their abortion beliefs in a heartbeat. Rather than payoff the abortion industry under the table in the healthcare reform bill, they could simply introduce a bill that asserts abortion as a legal right, preempts any state laws that restrict or regulate it, and offer to have the federal government pay for it. The majority party certainly has the votes in the House to do it. The Senate would be trickier, but whatever they came up with, Pres. Obama would sign it. 

            But the left lacks the courage of its own convictions. That’s why any healthcare bill would exempt members of Congress, so they could continue receiving their current gold-plated health benefits. So NARAL toadies like Chairman Waxman rely on parliamentary ruses to pay off their campaign debts but not have to answer to an angry American public, which is getting angrier by the day. 

            Just thought you might like to know.


Friday, August 14, 2009

"When We Took Over the Government"


I remember sitting in a meeting back in the mid-1990s and listening to a federal bureaucrat named Elaine Kamarck, a Clinton appointee, talked about all of the changes that the administration had made since 1993. To make the point about how life was different under the Clintons as opposed to 12 years of Republican administration, she juxtaposed then and now, using the phrase "when we took over the government." I had visions of Daniel Ortega pistoleros vaulting the White House fence off of Pennsylvania Ave. Hillary sitting in the Oval Office, wearing camo, boots up on the desk, drawing on a Cuban cigar.

I had my second when-we-took-over-the-government moment this week reading about the Obama counterattack on the furor building over his surreptitious plan to nationalize healthcare:


The town hall meetings are American democracy at its best. The tide has turned on Pres. Obama, although he doesn't know it yet. He is an academic liberal, a policy wonk, more comfortable in the salons of DC or New York than in upstate Pennsylvania or backwoods Alabama. The reason the tide has turned is that opponents of the President have drawn him out of the Beltway and made him fight on Main Street where he's not comfortable. 

The President's answer so far is to stay within his comfort zone. He is relying on support from special interest groups like the AARP, the AMA, or Big Labor--veteran Beltway lobbyists--to win the battle for him. 

In doing so, the President has set up an us-against-them scenario. In his mind and the minds of advisors David Axelrod, Rahm Emmanuel, Linda Douglass, and mouthpiece Robert Gibbs, they've taken over the government and they don't like being told what they can't do. 

Under this scenario it appears that we--the American people--have become the opponents, of our own government, according to Axelrod's spam message.  I am indignant and find it reprehensible that a president and his administration would think of the American people as his opposition.

Guess what, Dave? You haven't taken over anything. You control a building or two. Maybe state-run media. But that's not the government. The government's in session right now on Main Street. Read Amendment X. 

Just thought you might like to know.

/div>


Tuesday, August 11, 2009

surrenderyourrighttofreespeech@whitehouse.gov

President Obama's vision of nationalizing the healthcare industry is going down in flames. Congressmen home for the August recess are getting an earful from constituents upset at this radicalization of an important component of modern life. 


div>
So the President's answer: create another czar, or in this case, a czarina: Linda Douglass, former ABC newsie, and now the President's communications director for healthcare reform. Over the last year this blog has accused Democrats of failing to debate on issues and facts, and instead falling back on emotion and sound bites. Ms. Douglass is no exception. She is nothing if not unique in her strategy to avoid being drawn into debate.

Rather than pit one healthcare plan against another, her strategy is pit one American against another. She has created a website where you can go to rat out your fellow citizens if you think they are against the President's plan. So much for the first post-partisan president.

Well, Ms. Douglass, I wish to report an incident of disinformation on the healthcare debate. There is a website called flag@whitehouse.gov which is spreading falsehoods. On the home page it calls those of us who differ with the President "defenders of the status quo." Nothing could be farther from the truth. We believe in healthcare reform. That's why we oppose the President on this issue. His plan has less to do with reform and more to do with ideology. We fail to see how a trillion dollar plan is going to save money. We think American healthcare is pretty good, but way too expensive. We want to wring cost out of the system, preserve the incentives for innovative care solutions, and put Americans in charge of their own healthcare decisions. Hardly a status quo approach.

But if readers of this blog think I'm not a good American for wanting to do that, do me a favor. Go to the site, flag@whitehouse.gov, and rat me out. Right now. Perhaps the publicity will be good for the blog. If any reporter from the Wall Street Journal or Fox News finds out about it, the resulting publicity is sure to energize the blogosphere. That, in turn, will raise our Internet search rankings, resulting in even more readers. Far from stifling debate, flag@whitehouse.gov may result in a swelling tide of opinion against the President's ill-conceived plan. 

I could end up with a book deal. It's the American way.

Just thought you might like to know!