Friday, December 18, 2009

Senate Bill Proves ObamaCare Will Ration Healthcare

Let's dispense with the subtleties: The current healthcare deform bill on the verge of passing the Senate will reduce your care, increase your cost, place a bureaucrat between you and  your doctor and ultimately ration your care. Period. Anyone who says differently is lying, stupid or both. There can be no  varying degrees of interpretation at this point. It's in the bill.

Don't believe me? Check out Sen. Tom Coburn's op-ed piece in the Dec. 17, 2009 Wall Street Journal ("The Health Bill Is Scary"). Sen. Coburn (R-OK) brings two distinct advantages to this debate that the socialized medicine cheerleaders don't. First, he's actually read the bill. Second, he's a practicing physician of 25 years. He understands the practical implications of health policy decisions being made by 25-year-old Hill interns and Obama White House policy wonks.

It is also worth noting that Sen. Coburn is a two-time cancer survivor . So having stared down the barrel of the Grim Reaper's gun twice, he understands what's at stake here in a way those policy wonks will never be able to.

"Every American, not just seniors, should know that the rationing provisions in the Senate bill will not only reduce their quality of life, but their life span as well," he writes.

Why so? Well, here's the unvarnished truth that is in the bill:
  • Sections 3403 and 2021 clearly tell Medicare to deny coverage if it is deemed too expensive. The law would create a stronger "Independent Medicare Advisory Board ," the function of which will be to stretch Medicare dollars by rationing care. The board would be composed, according to Sen. Coburn, of "permanent, unelected, and, therefore, unaccountable members." This is the Death Panel at which Democrats scoffed and denied its existence. 
  • Sections 6301 mandates creation of "comparative effectiveness research (CER) programs . These are modeled on the "Quality Adjusted Life Years " panels used for years by the British National Health Service. In Britain this form of rationing has been responsible 15,000 premature cancer deaths each year, according to that country's National Cancer Intelligence Network . QALYs are "black box actuarial tables " that are used to cost justify denying you treatment. Essentially are like the cost-benefit analysis that a corporation uses to justify any investment. If the bureaucrat in charge deems that you don't have enough time left on earth for the government to recover its investment in a drug, surgery or other treatment, or to return that investment to society (i.e. if you are retired and no longer productive), then you'll be denied the treatment, regardless of what your physician recommends. Count on it. 
  • Section 2713 of the Senate bill explicitly mandates that the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force approve all health insurance plan coverages. The Task Force, you may remember from last month, is the group that issued an advisory for women under age 50 not to undergo annual mammograms. The president claims, disingenuously, that the Task Force pronouncements do not carry the force of law. But when he signs this bill, they will. Just watch how many insurers in 2010 try to get ahead of the bow wave and drop mammogram coverage for women under 50. This is a form of rationing.
The bill also expands the number of people eligible for Medicaid, the government-run healthcare program formerly for poor people. But Medicaid is already rationed. Because the government is too inept at running it, many doctors wait nearly 6 months for reimbursement for care provided under the program. It also underpays doctors. For these reasons many doctors refuse to take Medicaid patients.

In Maryland, according to Sen. Coburn's analysis, 17,000 Medicaid patients are currently on a waiting list for treatment . As many as 250 may have died waiting to be cared for, according to the state. And in Kansas, where current Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius was governor, there is a backlog of more than 15,000 Medicaid patients waiting treatment. Sec. Sebelius would be in charge of ObamaCare. What's not in this bill is any guarantees that ObamaCare would be any less inept or inefficient than Medicaid. So get ready for the waiting lists. It's our future.

My point is not to scare anyone. It is to present an unheard voice in this debate, the voice of someone who is a practicing physician and also must vote on this bill. So if your Democrat friends start arguing with you about healthcare, giving you the same old anti-corporate, emotional Routine Number 8 from the 1960s playbook, you quote the bill--chapter and verse numbers--to them and ask them to deny it. It's time this bill was evaluated on the facts of what it is, not some idealistic dream of what the Democrats want it to be.

Just thought you might like to know.

Thursday, December 17, 2009

Just Thought You Might Like to Know: Democrats Unlease Their Venom on an Extraordinary Joe

Just Thought You Might Like to Know: Democrats Unlease Their Venom on an Extraordinary Joe

Democrats Unlease Their Venom on an Extraordinary Joe



Democrats lost a great deal of credibility from 2000 through 2008 by demonizing George W. Bush and reducing the political discourse in this country to something you'd hear in a bar fight. 


Republicans when debating policy tend to argue from facts. Democrats over the last decade, in absence of compelling evidence to support their positions, have tended to argue from emotion. Thus, every Republican president of my time has been  attacked by Democrats for some alleged personal flaw that has nothing to do with the underlying logic of their policies. Eisenhower? Inarticulate. Nixon? A crook. Ford? Stupid. Reagan? Senile. And stupid. George H.W. Bush? Out of touch. George W. Bush? Just plain stupid.


So in the absence of any Republican of star power right now except Sarah Palin (Viewed by the left as both not a real woman and a bimbo at the same time. Did we mention stupid?) to vilify, Democrats have turned their guns on one of their own--Connecticut Independent Sen. Joe Lieberman.


Sen. Lieberman's sin is being too independent. Let the record reflect that it was the Democrats themselves who made him an independent by pouring their salon money into the campaign of his primary opponent in 2006, Ned Lamont. (In keeping with their myth of being the party of the people, Mr. Lamont made his fortune the old fashioned way--he inherited from a father who was a partner in   J.P. Morgan and Co. Along the way to getting trounced by Sen. Lieberman in the general election, this man of the people had stops at exclusive prep school Phillips Exeter,  as well as Harvard and Yale.)


So, the Democrat swells who created Joe Lieberman, the independent, now vilify him for being, well, independent. Which brings us to healthcare. Jonathan Chait, writing in the New Republic , says that "Lieberman isn't actually all that smart...there's little evidence that he's a sharp or clear thinker, and certainly no evidence that he knows or cares about the details of health care reform. . . ." Isn't all that smart? Mr. Chait obviously has him confused with a Republican.


He goes on in his article amazingly to suggest that because Sen. Lieberman is a Jew, he benefits from reverse discrimination since the only reason most people probably think the senator is smart because they assume all Jews are smart. Way to go, Jon. Any opinion on Joe's athletic ability?


MoveOn.org , the ultra-leftist racket, is using the anti-Lieberman campaign as a fundraiser for themselves: "Joe Lieberman is single-handedly gutting health care reform. And it's time someone held him accountable. So we're going to make sure every voter in Connecticut knows what he's doing. And then, when he comes up for re-election, we'll make sure we send him home for good. Can you chip in to make Joe pay?" Leave it to a bunch of socialists to figure out how to make money out of the healthcare debate. Time for moveon.org to move on for good.


House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer blames lack of action on the Senate healthcare bill on Sen. Lieberman rather than the bill's many flaws. He shifts the blame for the Senate's ineptitude at failing to pass a bill  to the "psychology of one," meaning Sen Lieberman. If the psychology of one is really the reason the bill continues to be stuck in neutral, then that one is Rep. Hoyer's counterpart, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV). 


And Rep. Rosa DeLauro  (D-CT) tells POLITICO that "No individual should hold health care hostage, including Joe Lieberman, and I'll say it flat out, I think he ought to be recalled."


James Taranto of the Wall Street Journal reminds Rep. DeLauro that there is no provision for recalling members of Congress. Oops. Not a bright thing to say. Maybe she's a Republican.


This campaign of belittling its opponents smacks of the elitist institution that the Democrat Party has become. Well oiled and well funded by the Ned Lamonts and George Soroses of the world, it tries to accomplish its goals by gutter sniping rather than through reasoned discourse. In doing so, it is attacking a man, Joe Lieberman, more principled than any of them could ever hope to be. 


Just thought you might like to know.



Tuesday, December 15, 2009

The American Exceptionalist vs. the Internationalist

Barack Obama is the most articulate yet polarizing president since Ronald Reagan. George Friedman, writing for Stratfor , points out a number of similarities between the two:

  • Each succeeded a president who began his presidency with high hopes and support but squandered his popularity by the time he left office
  • The predecessors of both Reagan and Obama left office amid a serious recession
  • Each emphasized the foreign policy challeges that the faraway country of Afghanistan would present, although each for a different reason
  • Neither President Reagan nor President Obama enjoyed landslide victories over their opponents, each winning about half the votes cast
  • Each tried to change the way the world looked at the United States, although in different ways
Yet there are significant differences between the two presidents. President Reagan totally repudiated the foreign and military policy of his predecessor, the feckless Jimmy Carter. The Carter foreign policy was defined by the Iranian hostage crisis -50 Americans captured and held prisoner for over a year, along with their once proud nation. The Reagan foreign policy, on the other hand, was defined by  the bombing of Libya in swift retailiation for the Libyan bombing of a German night club in which American service personnel died. ("They put one of yours in the hospital, you put one of theirs in the morgue .")

President Obama, on the other hand, for all of his left-leaning rhetoric, has largely continued the policies of his precessor George W. Bush, according to Friedman. He continues to prosecute the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, adding troops to the latter and continuing Pres. Bush's strategy in the former. He has continued the Bush policy of Nato expansion in to Georgia and Ukraine. And he has adopted the Bush strategy of advocating sanctions in the case of some the worlds bad actors in places like Iran and North Korea.

Yet there is a stark difference between Presidents Reagan and Obama, with regard to foreign policy. Pres. Reagan was a firm believer in American exceptionalism . American exceptionalism is the belief that America is a unique country with a special role to play in human history. Turning the tide in two world wars. The Marshall Plan to save post-War Europe from economic collapse. Countless rescue and recovery missions in the face of natural disasters. Inventions and innovations. A land of bountiful opportunity. For Pres Reagan, American was and will always be that "shining city on a hill ."

Pres. Obama, on the other hand is an internationalist. He believes that among nations no country, the U.S. included, stands above any other. Americans who view the president cautiously point to his apparent bowing to foreign leaders like Emporer Akihito  of Japan or the Saudi king , his speech in Cairo  apologizing for alleged past American transgressions against the Muslim world, and his deference to the opinions of other world leaders as evidence that he does not believe that America stands above other nations.

This difference is keenly seen in the views held by non-Americans of the two men. While Pres. Reagan grew in popularity at home as his muscular foreign policy took shape, he was, frankly, reviled  in Europe. Conversely Pres. Obama's popularity at home continues to drop as American exceptionalism declines, and the Europeans love him for it, to the point of awarding him the Nobel Prize for Peace, albeit with no real reason to do so.

President Reagan's foreign policy restored America's confidence in itself both at home and abroad. In his first year as president, Mr. Obama's internationalism has yielded few results, other than his own Nobel Prize. The longer this goes on, the more likely we are to slip into the "malaise " of defeatism that marked the Carter presidency. Pres. Obama has time to turn it around, to create a foreign policy that will define his presidency and restory the confidence of Americans in themselves as an exceptional country.

But the time for doing that is beginning to run out.

Just thought you might like to know. 

If You Thought the News Out of Washington Is Bizarre...

With so much depressing news coming out of Washington these days--healthcare, the deficit, raising taxes, getting tweaked by Iran every two weeks--it might be a good time to take a look at some news that's really bizarre. Might make us fee good by comparison:
  • Police in Shelbyville, Tennessee say they arrested a woman for passing out drunk  while riding a horse in a town Christmas parade. Fifteen minutes after getting a report of ripped rider in the parade, investigating cops found a woman passed out drunk on a horse outside of a nearby motel. She was cited for public drunkeness.
  • A couple of Pennsylvania college students were arrested recently for not paying a tip at a local pub. It seems that the pub required an 18 percent tip on tables of six or more customers. The two students nixed the tip because they said the service was awful. According to the two scholars, they had to scrounge around for their own table settings and napkins while the server cadged a smoke outside, then had to wait over an hour for their chicken wings. They'll tell it to a judge next month.
  • Months after passing a bill legalizing gay marriage, New Hampshire lawmakers are getting around to repealing a 200-year law that makes adultery a crime in the Granite State. New Hampshire adulterers currently face a $1,200 fine if convicted. That's better than the original punishment which was standing on the gallows for an hour with a noose around  your neck. Serious offenders faced 39 lashes if convicted. Good thing Tiger Woods doesn't live there.
  • A couple of Utah teenagers were arrested for rapping their order  at a Salt Lake City-area McDonald's restaurant drive-thru. The kids say they were just imitating a popular You Tube video . The store said the budding hip hoppers were holding up the line. Police tracked the singers to a local high school where they were issued a summons. Never confuse Mickey D with Clay D  .
So, the next time you shake your head at the nightly news, remember, it could be worse!

Just thought you might like to know!

Monday, December 14, 2009

You Don't Need an Economics Degree to Spot a Climate Scam


One of the first rules of business I ever learned is that everything in this world comes down to money. I remember an old cartoon in Mad  magazine that spoofed the opening of the 1960s Ben Casey  television show, one of the first hospital dramas. In that scene the wise old Dr. Zorba played by the actor Sam Jaffe  would stand at a blackboard and instruct young residents on the facts of life, scratching in chalk  the symbols: man, woman, birth, death, infinity. To this Mad added a sixth fact of life: the dollar sign.

I think of this scene often when I'm trying to understand the controversy over global warming--man-made climate change, for you more liberally inclined readers. For most of us the "evidence" of global warming is inconclusive or contradictory at best. Yet the climatologists who drink the global warming Kool-Aid say the subject is settled and the "fact" of man-made climate change is truth. The question is why.

And the answer, as Dr. Zorba could have told us, is the dollar sign. If doing good involves saving the planet, then  apparently you can do very well by doing good. The unfolding scandal over   "Climategate " (see our Dec. 7, 2009) post, raises the issue of why the climatologists in questions were so conspiratorial. As scientists, shouldn't they be interested in a free and frank exchange of data  and not try to bury opposing theories? Well, short answer, no.

It seems that the academics in the crosshairs of this controversy may have been motivated by more than science. The Wall Street Journal has reported that the British University of East Anglia's Climate Research Unit  has netted nearly £12 million as the climate scare has escalated over the decade.

And Michael Mann, another name that comes up in the purloined Climategate emails, was even more proficient. By 2007, two years after he joined Penn State University , the institution had brought in some $55 million in climate research funding, most of it supplied by the government.

So there's big money to be made in saving the planet. That explains the fear tactics ginned up by climate researchers. This is no longer about science or health. It's about money. It's not Thomas Edison and Louis Pasteur. It's Toyota v. Honda.

Several years ago, before the doubts and before Climategate, the best selling author Michael Crichton satirized this global warming industry in novel State of Fear . In it a major environmental "non-profit," which is a thinly veiled send-up of one of the world's leading environmental organizations, rakes in millions of dollars in donations by duping easily duped Hollywood stars into cheerleading for this nonsense.

As an avid outdoorsman, I firmly believe we have an obligation to minimize our footprint on the planet as we go through life.(Pack in, pack out) But, please, don't believe that the current nonsense coming out of formerly esteemed research institutions has anything to do with meeting that obligation.

If anybody asks you what the current flap over climategate is all about, tell them the truth. Tell them it's all about the money.

Just thought you might like to know. 

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Democrat Plan to Steal the 2012 Election?

The Obambi.com blog has an interesting take on the 2010 presidential election. It's no secret that President Obama's popularity is sinking like a stone. The conservative Democrats, independents, and disgruntled Republicans who put him in the White House are now having a severe case of buyer's remorse. If the presidential election were held on Wednesday, he'd be a lame duck president by Thursday.

But George Soros, the far-left financier that has helped bankroll Democrat politics has another idea: If you can't control enough voters to re-elect the president, control the state secretaries-of-state who count the votes.

Soros believes that voters don't wield political power; the bureaucrats and politicians who decide whose votes count do. So he's concocted a scheme worthy of any Chicago pol: Send his accolytes out to the hinterlands and elect ultra-left secretary-of-state candidates in 2010 so that they can steal the election from the voters by deciding which votes to count and which to disqualify in 2012.

This would be a Machievellian move that would make Leon Trotsky blush. Click here to read. You won't believe it. I'm having a hard time figuring out if this is any different than what Hugo Chavez, Hamid Karzai or the Iranian mullahs have done. Maybe we should ask the UN to send international poll watchers in 2012. Where's Jimmy Carter when you need him?

The irony is that Democrats are proving to be decidedly undemocratic.

Just thought you might like to know.


The Dealmaker